After Babri, Gyanvapi, after that…

I called S M Yaseen to ask about the meaning he read in the 30th anniversary of the demolition of the Babri Masjid which falls tomorrow December 6 After remaining silent long enough for me to think the call had dropped Yaseen said ldquoThe way things are we will have more such anniversaries in the futurerdquo Yaseen is the joint secretary of the Anjuman Intezamia Masajid which is responsible for the upkeep of the Gyanvapi masjid in VaranasiBesieged by as many as 18 lawsuits the defence of Gyanvapirsquos Islamic identity weakened earlier this year with the Supreme Court ruling in effect that a survey of its complex controversially claiming a fountain in the ablution pool to be a Shivling was not in violation of the Places of Worship Act 1991 This Act freezes the religious character of a place of worship as it was on August 15 1947The Supreme Courtrsquos logic was that the Act does not debar ascertaining the religious character of a place of worship It only proscribes turning say a mosque into a temple The survey of the Gyanvapi masjid was ordered by a Varanasi civil court acting on a petition filed by five women pleading that they be allowed to worship Maa Shringar Gauri and other deities supposedly present there These women are not historians or archaeologists curious about the religious provenance of a structure They wish to pray there in a bid to appropriate the mosque for HindusAlso Read Planning crucial before setting up night bazaarsThe ascertainment process will create a tide of opinion for usurping the Gyanvapi mosque as had happened with the Babri Masjid site that was ultimately handed over through a 2019 Supreme Court judgment to the HindusTrue the Act does not explicitly debar ascertaining the religious character of a place of worship But then the Constitution also does not provide for the collegium system for selecting judges Yet the Supreme Court has been impressively assertive in protecting its turf from executive encroachments Could it not have shown the same enthusiasm for protecting Gyanvapi from the insidious designs of the Hindutva brigadeThis question assumes importance in the backdrop of several masjidmandir disputes simmering countrywide A Mathura court has already ruled that petitions seeking the removal of the Shahi Eidgah mosque from the Krishna Janmabhoomi site do not fall within the ambit of the Places of Worship Act There are litigations pertaining to the religious character of the Shamsi Jama masjid in Badaun Uttar Pradesh as well Such mosquetemple disputes include BhagyalakshmiCharminar in Hyderabad Baba BudangiriGuru Dattatreya shrine in Karnataka and the BhojshalaKamal Maula Mosque in Madhya Pradesh Hindutva acolytes anyway claim that Muslim rulers destroyed 3000 temples to build mosques in their placeBut now even the Places of Worship Act has been challenged in the Supreme Court which will begin hearing the case next month Muslims like Yaseen worry because they have seen every judicial pronouncement in the Ayodhya dispute expand the rights of Hindus over the Babri Masjid In case the Act is struck down 3000 new reasons will be found to target 3000 mosquesThe Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and its affiliates are able to mobilise people on masjidmandir disputes because of the myths spawned by school textbooksmdashthe only history most Indians read in their lives These textbooks sought to give cultural roots to the passive resistance against the British colonial rule building upon the efforts of national movement stalwarts Gandhi and Nehru included to construct a past in which India was depicted to have been the abode of nonviolence before the advent of MuslimsThe foremost among these myths was that Buddhism disappeared from India because it was absorbed through debates and accommodations into Hinduism None of our school textbooks detail how Pushyamitra Shunga in 185 BCE overthrew the Buddhist Mauryan dynasty destroyed the Kukkutarama monastery in Pataliputra vandalised the Sanchi stupa and killed Buddhist monks wantonly The genocidal violence against the Buddhists continued through the centuries described vividly in Giovanni Verardirsquos Hardships and Downfall of Buddhism in IndiaHindu rulers attacked temples long before Muslims made India their home Victorious Hindu kings would plunder the temples their vanquished opponents patronised ferret away the deities installed there and in some cases even break them As early as 642 CE the Pallava ruler Narasimhavarman I defeated the Chalukyas sacked their capital Vatapi and brought the idol of Ganesha to his kingdom in Tamil Nadu In the early 10th century the Rashtrakuta king Indra III destroyed the temple of Kalapriya which the Pratiharas patronised For more such instances read Richard H Davidrsquos essay Indian Art Objects as LootA history sanitised of Hindu violence ingrains a sense of exceptionalism among Hindus as is likely true of that teacher of the Manipal Institute of Technology who called a Muslim student Kasab the terrorist hanged for the 2611 Mumbai massacre The student riposted ldquoBeing a Muslim and facing this every day in this country is not funnyrdquo What the student did not explicitly say constitutes the meaning of the 30th anniversary of the demolition of the Babri Masjidmdashthat it is grim and scary to be a Muslim in todayrsquos IndiaThe writer is a senior journalistSend your feedback to mailbagmiddaycomThe views expressed in this column are the individualrsquos and donrsquot represent those of the paper