Mumbai: Not an inch of our cemetery land, say activists

A recently served notice by the BMC to the overcenturyold St Peterrsquos Seaside Cemetery Bandra seeking a slice of the land for road widening has hurt the religious sentiments of thousands of Roman Catholics in the city They have now decided to sign a petition demanding that the civic body withdraw its decisionCatholics told midday that the BMC as a part of its development plan was supposed to provide land for burials and cremations But it has given a notice to take a portion of our centuryold cemetery How mean said an activistFr Frazer Mascarenhas SJ the parish priest of St Peters Church said that slums and illegal structures had come up in the wake of the reclamation of land but the civic body was seeking a portion of the cemetery to widen the roadThe Bombay Catholic Sabha has called a meeting to save St Peterrsquos Seaside Cemetery at Bandra PicsPradeep DhivarSome activists have alleged that the civic officials have become tools at the hands of people with vested interests and alleged that some civic officials were using official machinery to armtwist church authorities Others have asked the civic body and other government bodies what they were doing when the slums and illegal structures were coming upThe Bombay Catholic Sabha will hold an urgent meeting on Friday at Loyola Hall St Peterrsquos Church in Bandra Dolphy Drsquosouza president of the group has requested people to show up in large numbers ldquoWe plan to oppose this injustice with the peoplersquos supportrdquo he saidAlso Read Human Rights courts where are they asks ActivistsAnthony Lobo whose ancestors are buried in the cemetery said ldquoThe notice has hurt the religious sentiments of Catholics all over the world I have received messages about the notice from friends and relatives who have settled abroad If the BMC decides to take a slice of the land it will create chaosrdquoFr Mascarenhas said ldquoThe BMC served the church a notice about its intention to take a slice of the corner of St Peters Seaside Cemetery for road widening A larger portion of the Jewish Cemetery across the road is also being taken This will mean the demolishing of about 20 permanent graves along with the wall in that areardquoldquoOur cemetery is more than a century old and was established in an isolated area with the sea on the rear side Reclamation of land has resulted in slums and illegal structures coming up there to which access is sought to be given However there already exists a parallel road for which Catholic colonies had given up land in the pastrdquo he addedA message that is being shared by Catholics reads ldquoThis is a sacred space where religious worship is conducted once a year and where families come all year round to pray for their loved ones Taking away the land of an established cemetery along with permanent graves of families will hurt Catholic sentimentsldquoThe parish will therefore request the BMC to withdraw this notice and seek other sources of access that are available to those in that area behind the cemeteryrdquo said Fr MascarenhasAdvocate Godfrey Pimenta an activist from Watchdog Foundation said ldquoThis is a criminal conspiracy hatched by officials of the BMC in connivance with the developer who intends to develop the sprawling and illegal slum colony adjacent to the cemetery and the notice dated December 19 2022 issued by the joint municipal commissioner zone 3 H West ward is engineered in furtherance of the said criminal conspiracyrdquoldquoThe adjoining slum colony does not have a road with sufficient width so as to sanction an SRA scheme and the notice has been issued to accommodate the requirements of the developer to implement the schemerdquo he addedldquoA similar conspiracy was hatched in the case of Bamanwada Gaothan a year ago when a narrow lane having bungalows with a compound wall were bulldozed by K East ward officials to accommodate the local developerrsquos needrdquo he saidPimenta further alleged ldquoSome civic officials have become handmaids of those with vested interests who for pecuniary gain are using official machinery to armtwist church authorities and likeminded persons which we will not allow at any costrdquoVivian DrsquoSouza an advisor at Watchdog Foundation said ldquoRecently the Bombay High Court had asked the Maharashtra government what was the point of granting permissions for the construction of skyscrapers when there is no place for burial grounds in Mumbai The bench of Chief Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Madhav Jamdar was hearing a public interest litigation filed by one Mohammed Furqan Qureshi seeking a separate burial ground for Sunni Muslims in BandrardquoHe added ldquoThe corporation as a part of its development plan is supposed to provide lands for burial grounds and crematoria However it has failed to do so A classic example of this is the land allotted to Christians in the SEEPZ area near JVLR which is yet to be put to use The families of the dead have been inconvenienced since bodies have to be taken from Marol to Sewri or Oshiwara for burial which is not only costly but also timeconsumingrdquo he saidDrsquoSouza stated that if the corporation cannot provide land for burials and cremation grounds it has no right to snatch the cemetery and that too to accommodate the greed of a developerIt is our experience that whenever roads are widened by the corporation the same are eaten up by illegal hawkers or illegal parking takes place A classic case of this is the beautified and widened Andheri Kurla Road from Andheri East station to Saki Naka Hawkers have encroached upon it completely For whose benefit the corporation is widening roads in Mumbai and in particular Kadeshwari Mata Mandhir Road Bandra West Mumbai 400050 is a milliondollar questionrdquo he saidldquoIn the past similar attempts were made to widen Hill Road in Bandra which was vehemently resisted by the Christian and Parsi communities Kadeshwari Mata Mandhir Road reaches a dead end from Chapel Road and its widening is totally unjustified and uncalled forrdquo he saidAdvocate Tulip Brian Miranda president Bombay East Indian Association and a former corporator said We call upon you the BMC to cease and desist from going ahead with the acquisition of cemetery land failing which we will have no option but to agitate along with members of the Bombay Catholic Sabha and other organisationsrdquoR Dhakane deputy municipal commissioner zone 3 meanwhile justified the move stating We issued a notice for the demolition of some part of the cemetery for the future development of roads As per the requirement roads should be 915 metres wide This road is too small and needs to widening Only 3 to 4 per cent of the cemetery plot will be demolished We have only issued a notice and have not yet acted Many people are making the issue a religious one If roads are not widened no development will happenHistory under threatThe over100yearold St Peterrsquos Seaside Cemetery was most likely established during the Plague of Bombay at the turn of the century that continued for more than two decadesSenior architect urban planner and conservationist David Cardoz said ldquoThe Bandra Municipality is most likely to have identified this land to ensure that the dead who perished from the plague were buried away from habitation Plans reveal that the wall of the cemetery hit the sea Over time reclamation occurred and encroachments sprung up so the location has alteredrdquoCardoz said the community is united to save this land ldquoThey shouldnrsquot be taking away graves We intend to fight for what is oursrdquo he said adding ldquoAll burial grounds are important We need adequate reasons to understand why this notice was servedrdquoThe architect believes that approximately 20 graves near the periphery of the cemeteryrsquos boundary wall could be affected He revealed that the community will fight on two issues Firstly hurting public sentiment and secondly intent ldquoWhen you serve notices think of those you are serving it to You are aware that a cemetery exists here that is older than the BMC Today you say Give it up in the interest of developmentrsquordquo Spelling out the fallout of this decision he said ldquoWhat happens to the graves that will get affected Our cemetery is full This location was a dead end in the past What is the real reason to widen this road An alternate DP development plan road was planned that would lead to the reclamation But this road goes up the hill and comes to a dead end so whatrsquos the point That road work from that alternate plan was stopped and instead this road is being widenedrdquoPutting things into perspective he said ldquoWhen there is genuine public interest involved for a civic matter the church will always be the first to step up Today itrsquos a ninemetre extension tomorrow we donrsquot know if more will be required A good planner is aware that some things like a place of religious significance cannot be touched Most importantly they focus on the larger picturerdquoInputs by Fiona Fernandez19Day in December when notice was issued